Wednesday
10 May 2017 · UTAS Faculty of Law

Room 1 · Noah Grubb (shadow) · Tom Marshall

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:10 PM S2017DN025 Novice Taroona High School 3 St Michael's Collegiate 1 That school rules should be made by students Affirmative win
8:10 PM 9:40 PM S2017DC031 College St Mary's College 1 The Hutchins School 1 That juries should return "not guilty" verdicts where they believe it would be unjust for defendants to be punished Affirmative win by negative forfeit

Room 2 · Johanna Ellis

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:10 PM S2017DN026 Novice The Friends' School 1 The Friends' School 3 That school rules should be made by students Negative win
7:10 PM 8:10 PM S2017D9023 Class 9 Dominic College 1 Fahan School 1 That we should break unjust laws Negative win
8:10 PM 9:40 PM S2017DC026 College St Michael's Collegiate 1 Guilford Young College 1 That juries should return "not guilty" verdicts where they believe it would be unjust for defendants to be punished Affirmative win

Room 3 · Reuben Mackey (trial) · Kathryn Ellis (observer)

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:10 PM S2017DN028 Novice New Town High School 1 Taroona High School 5 That school rules should be made by students Affirmative win
7:10 PM 8:10 PM S2017D9025 Class 9 St Michael's Collegiate 1 The Friends' School 2 That we should break unjust laws Affirmative win
8:10 PM 9:40 PM S2017DC028 College The Friends' School 4 The Friends' School 3 That juries should return "not guilty" verdicts where they believe it would be unjust for defendants to be punished Affirmative win

Room 4 · Peter Legg

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:10 PM S2017DN029 Novice The Friends' School 2 Taroona High School 2 That school rules should be made by students Negative win
7:10 PM 8:10 PM S2017D9022 Class 9 Ogilvie High School 2 Ogilvie High School 1 That we should break unjust laws Affirmative win
7:10 PM 8:10 PM S2017D9026 Class 9 The Friends' School 3 The Hutchins School 1 That we should break unjust laws Affirmative win by negative forfeit
8:10 PM 9:40 PM S2017DC029 College The Friends' School 1 Fahan School 1 That juries should return "not guilty" verdicts where they believe it would be unjust for defendants to be punished Affirmative win

Room 5 · Adam Irwin (trial) · James Barnes (observer)

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:10 PM S2017DN030 Novice Dominic College 1 St Mary's College 1 That school rules should be made by students Negative win
7:10 PM 8:10 PM S2017D9027 Class 9 The Friends' School 1 Clarence High School 1 That we should break unjust laws Affirmative win
8:10 PM 9:40 PM S2017DC030 College The Hutchins School 3 Hobart College 2 That juries should return "not guilty" verdicts where they believe it would be unjust for defendants to be punished Negative win

Room 6 · Mel Ross · Clodagh Daley-Crawford

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:10 PM S2017DN031 Novice Ogilvie High School 1 The Hutchins School 1 That school rules should be made by students Negative win by affirmative late forfeit
7:10 PM 8:10 PM S2017D9028 Class 9 St Mary's College 1 Dominic College 2 That we should break unjust laws Negative win
8:10 PM 9:40 PM S2017DC025 College Hobart College 1 Guilford Young College 2 That juries should return "not guilty" verdicts where they believe it would be unjust for defendants to be punished Negative win

Room 7 · Vivian Imbriotis

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:10 PM S2017DN032 Novice Taroona High School 1 Taroona High School 4 That school rules should be made by students Affirmative win by negative forfeit
7:10 PM 8:10 PM S2017D9024 Class 9 Taroona High School 1 Taroona High School 2 That we should break unjust laws Negative win
8:10 PM 9:40 PM S2017DC032 College The Hutchins School 2 Elizabeth College 1 That juries should return "not guilty" verdicts where they believe it would be unjust for defendants to be punished Negative win

Room 8 · Caroline De Paoli

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:10 PM S2017DN027 Novice Fahan School 1 St Mary's College 2 That school rules should be made by students Negative win