Peter Legg (Adjudicator: Level 5)

Peter is also a debater. You may wish to look at his debater profile.

Average scores

# Matter Manner Method POI Total Rank
S* 714 30.16 30.33 14.92 +0.01 75.41 3.50
R* 80 14.91 15.21 7.42 37.54
1A 119 30.03 30.08 15.04 +0.10 75.18 3.76
2A 119 30.24 30.40 14.95 -0.03 75.58 3.34
3A 119 30.05 30.40 14.86 +0.15 75.36 3.66
RA 40 14.93 15.20 7.39 37.51
1N 119 30.16 30.38 14.97 0.00 75.51 3.44
2N 119 30.19 30.24 14.82 -0.10 75.22 3.61
3N 119 30.27 30.50 14.87 -0.05 75.63 3.20
RN 40 14.90 15.23 7.45 37.58

Adjudications

Date Debate Topic Affirmative Negative Round Rules Margin
28 May 2025 S2025DT030 That, assuming the technology exists and works perfectly, we should allow parents to genetically modify their unborn children Mount Carmel College 1 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2025 Grade Ten Round 5 Class 10 2.5
28 May 2025 S2025DN023 That we should invest in space tourism Hobart City High School 1 Fahan School 1 Southern Schools 2025 Novice Round 5 Novice 1
21 May 2025 S2025DC021 That, as soon as the technology for any given profession exists, we should replace all workers with robots Hobart College 1 Fahan School 1 Southern Schools 2025 College Round 5 College 4
21 May 2025 S2025D8029 That we prefer a world in which a perfectly functional truth serum exists The Hutchins School 2 The Friends' School 4 Southern Schools 2025 Grade Eight Round 5 Class 8 3
21 May 2025 S2025D8031 That we prefer a world in which a perfectly functional truth serum exists Australian Christian College 1 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2025 Grade Eight Round 5 Class 8 6
7 May 2025 S2025DC017 That we regret cancel culture The Friends' School 1 Hobart College 1 Southern Schools 2025 College Round 4 College 5
7 May 2025 S2025D8025 That we should all be vegans Taroona High School 1 Australian Christian College 1 Southern Schools 2025 Grade Eight Round 4 Class 8 3
7 May 2025 S2025D8024 That we should all be vegans Hobart City High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 2 Southern Schools 2025 Grade Eight Round 4 Class 8 3
30 April 2025 S2025DT016 That we should lower the tax on petrol Taroona High School 1 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2025 Grade Ten Round 3 Class 10 1
30 April 2025 S2025DN012 That pocket money should be banned Clarence High School 1 Clarence High School 2 Southern Schools 2025 Novice Round 3 Novice 4
26 March 2025 S2025DC008 That we should dissolve political parties that represent fringe viewpoints Fahan School 1 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2025 College Round 2 College 12.5
26 March 2025 S2025D8010 That the voting age should be lowered Clarence High School 1 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2025 Grade Eight Round 2 Class 8 7
26 March 2025 S2025D8013 That the voting age should be lowered The Friends' School 3 Australian Christian College 1 Southern Schools 2025 Grade Eight Round 2 Class 8 3
19 March 2025 S2025DT004 That DeepSeek is a force for good The Hutchins School 2 Hobart City High School 1 Southern Schools 2025 Grade Ten Round 1 Class 10 14.5
19 March 2025 S2025D9001 That all schoolwork should be marked by artificial intelligence Clarence High School 1 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2025 Grade Nine Round 1 Class 9 7
19 March 2025 S2025DN004 That ChatGPT has done more harm than good Clarence High School 1 Hobart City High School 1 Southern Schools 2025 Novice Round 1 Novice 5
12 March 2025 S2025DC004 That we regret the release of artificial intelligence to the public The Friends' School 1 Rosny College 1 Southern Schools 2025 College Round 1 College 2.5
12 March 2025 S2025D8004 That we would prefer a world without artificial intelligence The Friends' School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2025 Grade Eight Round 1 Class 8 1
31 July 2024 S2024D9SF1 That we should prioritise promotion of ecotourism over preservation of the natural environment The Hutchins School 1 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2024 Grade Nine Semi finals Class 9 4
3 July 2024 S2024D8SF1 That we should convert national parks into housing developments Hobart City High School 1 Clarence High School 1 Southern Schools 2024 Grade Eight Semi finals Class 8 10
3 July 2024 S2024DNSF2 That public transport should be free St Michael's Collegiate 3 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2024 Novice Semi finals Novice 3
26 June 2019 S2019D8SF2 That all students should be required to study the arts The Friends' School 2 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Eight Semi finals Class 8 4
26 June 2019 S2019D8SF1 That all students should be required to study the arts The Friends' School 1 Ogilvie High School 1 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Eight Semi finals Class 8 2
27 March 2019 S2019D9009 That we should stop shopping online Clarence High School 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Nine Round 2 Class 9 4
27 March 2019 S2019D8017 That we should implement a universal basic income Taroona High School 3 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Eight Round 2 Class 8 4
13 March 2019 S2019DT002 That approval for major developments should be determined by a community vote The Friends' School 2 Fahan School 1 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Ten Round 1 Class 10 5
13 March 2019 S2019D8009 That recycling is a waste of time Taroona High School 2 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Eight Round 1 Class 8 2
13 March 2019 S2019D8008 That recycling is a waste of time Taroona High School 6 Calvin Christian School 1 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Eight Round 1 Class 8 4
15 August 2018 S2018D9SF1 That social media should not be available to people under the age of eighteen St Michael's Collegiate 2 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Nine Semi finals Class 9 2
4 July 2018 S2018DTGF1 That we should ban research into artificial intelligence Taroona High School 1 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Ten Grand final Class 10 4
4 July 2018 S2018D8GF1 That animal testing should be banned New Town High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 2 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Eight Grand final Class 8 1
27 June 2018 S2018D9SF2 That we should ban mobile phones from schools St Mary's College 1 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Nine Semi finals Class 9 4
27 June 2018 S2018D8SF1 That parents should only be permitted to work during the hours their children are at school Taroona High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 2 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Eight Semi finals Class 8 1
27 June 2018 S2018DNSF2 That children should not be able to purchase junk food Taroona High School 1 Calvin Christian School 2 Southern Schools 2018 Novice Semi finals Novice 2
6 June 2018 S2018DT046 That we should open our borders to climate refugees St Mary's College 1 Taroona High School 3 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Ten Round 6 Class 10 10
6 June 2018 S2018D9048 That we should prioritise individual privacy over national security St Aloysius Catholic College 1 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Nine Round 6 Class 9 5
23 May 2018 S2018DT036 That all schools which offer grades eleven and twelve should be coeducational St Aloysius Catholic College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Ten Round 5 Class 10 3.5
23 May 2018 S2018D9039 That all students should be required to study the arts The Friends' School 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Nine Round 5 Class 9 2
23 May 2018 S2018D8034 That the school age should be lowered St Michael's Collegiate 1 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Eight Round 5 Class 8 5
2 May 2018 S2018DC019 That we should tie foreign aid to emissions reduction The Friends' School 3 Elizabeth College 1 Southern Schools 2018 College Round 3 College 13
2 May 2018 S2018DN017 That we should build a cable car on Mount Wellington / kunanyi Fahan School 1 Ogilvie High School 2 Southern Schools 2018 Novice Round 3 Novice 4
2 May 2018 S2018DN055 That we should build a cable car on Mount Wellington / kunanyi Taroona High School 4 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2018 Novice Round 3 Novice 4
4 April 2018 S2018DC012 That celebrities should stay out of the feminist movement Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 2 Southern Schools 2018 College Round 2 College 2
4 April 2018 S2018DN010 That we should ban beauty pageants Ogilvie High School 2 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2018 Novice Round 2 Novice 2
4 April 2018 S2018DN051 That we should ban beauty pageants Ogilvie High School 3 St Aloysius Catholic College 2 Southern Schools 2018 Novice Round 2 Novice 2
21 March 2018 S2018DC003 That, where no party can form majority government after a Tasmanian election, a re-election should automatically be held The Friends' School 3 St Michael's Collegiate 2 Southern Schools 2018 College Round 1 College 6
21 March 2018 S2018DN048 That young Tasmanians should be able to vote New Town High School 1 Taroona High School 6 Southern Schools 2018 Novice Round 1 Novice 1
14 March 2018 S2018DT008 That we should ban all financial donations to Tasmanian political parties St Aloysius Catholic College 1 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Ten Round 1 Class 10 6.5
14 March 2018 S2018D9006 That we should ban poker machines from pubs and clubs New Town High School 1 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Nine Round 1 Class 9 1
14 March 2018 S2018D8004 That we should reduce the number of local councils in Tasmania Clarence High School 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Eight Round 1 Class 8 10
31 July 2017 S2017DCSF1 That we should abolish the ATAR The Friends' School 4 The Hutchins School 3 Southern Schools 2017 College Semi finals College 6.5
5 July 2017 S2017DNGF1 That every student should learn a foreign language Taroona High School 1 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2017 Novice Grand final Novice 2
28 June 2017 S2017D8SF2 That school attendance should be voluntary Taroona High School 4 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Semi finals Class 8 1
28 June 2017 S2017D8SF1 That the school age should be lowered The Friends' School 2 New Town High School 2 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Semi finals Class 8 4
14 June 2017 S2017D8027 That democracy is no longer the best form of government St Mary's College 1 New Town High School 2 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Round 6 Class 8 3
7 June 2017 S2017DN048 That Australia should become a republic Taroona High School 1 St Mary's College 1 Southern Schools 2017 Novice Round 6 Novice 2
31 May 2017 S2017DT030 That Instagram is an art form Fahan School 1 Ogilvie High School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Ten Round 5 Class 10 4
31 May 2017 S2017D8025 That we should only study modern literature Taroona High School 4 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Round 5 Class 8 2
31 May 2017 S2017D8055 That funding public libraries is a waste of money Taroona High School 2 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Round 5 Class 8 1
17 May 2017 S2017DT020 That criminal trials should be televised The Hutchins School 1 Dominic College 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Ten Round 4 Class 10 2
17 May 2017 S2017D8017 That fines should be proportional to income The Friends' School 2 St Mary's College 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Round 4 Class 8 5
17 May 2017 S2017D8047 That fines should be proportional to income Taroona High School 3 Ogilvie High School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Round 4 Class 8 4
10 May 2017 S2017DC029 That juries should return "not guilty" verdicts where they believe it would be unjust for defendants to be punished The Friends' School 1 Fahan School 1 Southern Schools 2017 College Round 4 College 10
10 May 2017 S2017D9022 That we should break unjust laws Ogilvie High School 2 Ogilvie High School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Nine Round 4 Class 9 1
10 May 2017 S2017DN029 That school rules should be made by students The Friends' School 2 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2017 Novice Round 4 Novice 2
12 April 2017 S2017DN018 That we should spend more on defence St Mary's College 2 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Novice Round 3 Novice 1
29 March 2017 S2017DC015 That we should eliminate agricultural subsidies St Mary's College 1 Guilford Young College 2 Southern Schools 2017 College Round 2 College 1.5
29 March 2017 S2017D9014 That we should ban intensive animal farming St Mary's College 1 Fahan School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Nine Round 2 Class 9 2
29 March 2017 S2017DN015 That every household should have a vegetable garden Ogilvie High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2017 Novice Round 2 Novice 3
22 March 2017 S2017DT006 That homeschooling should be banned Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Ten Round 1 Class 10 1.5
22 March 2017 S2017D8005 That smacking should be banned St Mary's College 1 Taroona High School 6 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Round 1 Class 8 2
15 March 2017 S2017DC004 That we should implement parenting licences The Hutchins School 1 The Friends' School 4 Southern Schools 2017 College Round 1 College 8
15 March 2017 S2017D9004 That childcare should be free Dominic College 2 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Nine Round 1 Class 9 3
15 March 2017 S2017DN004 That children should be paid to do chores The Hutchins School 1 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Novice Round 1 Novice 4
21 September 2016 S2016DCGF1 That public healthcare should not be available to high income earners The Friends' School 1 Elizabeth College 2 Southern Schools 2016 College Grand final College 1.5
20 July 2016 S2016DCSF2 That we should privatise the ABC Elizabeth College 2 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2016 College Semi finals College 2
29 June 2016 S2016D9GF1 That there should be a tax on sugary drinks St Mary's College 1 Ogilvie High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Grand final Class 9 4
29 June 2016 S2016D8GF1 That all students should be required to play sport at lunchtime Taroona High School 2 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Eight Grand final Class 8 5
22 June 2016 S2016D9SF2 That the arts should be removed from the Australian curriculum The Friends' School 1 Ogilvie High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Semi finals Class 9 1
22 June 2016 S2016D9SF1 That all students should be required to study the arts St Mary's College 1 St Mary's College 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Semi finals Class 9 2
8 June 2016 S2016DT036 That there should be quotas for women in the Australian Parliament Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Ten Round 6 Class 10 4
8 June 2016 S2016D9033 That politicians should be paid more The Friends' School 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Round 6 Class 9 2
1 June 2016 S2016DC048 That the leaders of political parties should be democratically elected Elizabeth College 2 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2016 College Round 6 College 2.5
1 June 2016 S2016DN027 That the voting age should be lowered New Town High School 1 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 6 Novice 1
1 June 2016 S2016DN054 That the voting age should be lowered Taroona High School 6 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 6 Novice 3
25 May 2016 S2016DT029 That we should ban the burning of fossil fuels The Friends' School 2 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Ten Round 5 Class 10 2.5
25 May 2016 S2016D9026 That access to national parks should be free Fahan School 1 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Round 5 Class 9 4
25 May 2016 S2016D8030 That we should ban tourism in national parks The Hutchins School 2 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Eight Round 5 Class 8 1
11 May 2016 S2016DT021 That judges should be elected The Friends' School 3 The Hutchins School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Ten Round 4 Class 10 3.5
4 May 2016 S2016DC030 That judicial activism is bad for democracy Fahan School 1 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2016 College Round 4 College 1.5
4 May 2016 S2016DN018 That parents should be held responsible for crimes committed by their children Dominic College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 4 Novice 8
4 May 2016 S2016DN045 That parents should be held responsible for crimes committed by their children The Hutchins School 1 Taroona High School 4 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 4 Novice 2
6 April 2016 S2016DC020 That the Australian government should not comment on human right abuses in other countries The Friends' School 2 The Hutchins School 2 Southern Schools 2016 College Round 3 College 0.5
6 April 2016 S2016DN013 That we should change the date of Australia Day New Town High School 1 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 3 Novice 1
30 March 2016 S2016DT010 That broadcasters should be required to cover women's and men's sport equally Clarence High School 1 Dominic College 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Ten Round 2 Class 10 4
30 March 2016 S2016D9010 That we should abolish marriage The Friends' School 2 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Round 2 Class 9 1
30 March 2016 S2016D8011 That we should ban beauty pageants Dominic College 1 Fahan School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Eight Round 2 Class 8 4
23 March 2016 S2016DC013 That feminists should publicly denounce female celebrities who return to abusive partners The Friends' School 3 Elizabeth College 3 Southern Schools 2016 College Round 2 College 11
23 March 2016 S2016DN009 That all schools should be coeducational Mount Carmel College 1 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 2 Novice 2
23 March 2016 S2016DN038 That all schools should be coeducational Taroona High School 4 Ogilvie High School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 2 Novice 1
16 March 2016 S2016DT002 That Tasmania should introduce selective schools The Friends' School 1 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Ten Round 1 Class 10 3.5
16 March 2016 S2016D9002 That all school students should do the same subjects St Michael's Collegiate 1 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Round 1 Class 9 1
16 March 2016 S2016D8002 That school attendance should be voluntary New Town High School 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Eight Round 1 Class 8 3
9 March 2016 S2016DC003 That schools should be able to monitor students' browsing The Hutchins School 1 Hobart College 3 Southern Schools 2016 College Round 1 College 6
9 March 2016 S2016D9006 That all school students should do the same subjects St Mary's College 1 St Mary's College 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Round 1 Class 9 3
24 June 2015 S2015DTSF1 That only applied science is worth funding Taroona High School 1 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Ten Round 7 Class 10 1
24 June 2015 S2015D9SF2 That we should send settlers to Mars Taroona High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Nine Round 7 Class 9 1
24 June 2015 S2015D8SF1 That science is the best guide for life New Town High School 2 St Mary's College 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Eight Round 7 Class 8 3
27 May 2015 S2015DT029 That we should spend more on defence St Michael's Collegiate 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Ten Round 5 Class 10 2.5
27 May 2015 S2015DN034 That we should change our national flag Taroona High School 3 St Mary's College 1 Southern Schools 2015 Novice Round 5 Novice 1
27 May 2015 S2015D9023 That we value our sportspeople too highly Fahan School 1 St Mary's College 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Nine Round 5 Class 9 6
20 May 2015 S2015DC024 That we should tax high income parents for sending their kids to public school St Michael's Collegiate 1 Hobart College 3 Southern Schools 2015 College Round 4 College 2
20 May 2015 S2015D8R14 That we need more practical classes at school The Hutchins School 2 Dominic College 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Eight Round 4 Class 8 1
20 May 2015 S2015D8B14 That all high schools should go to Grade 12 Fahan School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Eight Round 4 Class 8 6
6 May 2015 S2015DC021 That we should end custodial sentences for minors Hobart College 2 The Hutchins School 2 Southern Schools 2015 College Round 3 College 9.5
6 May 2015 S2015D8R11 That criminals should be able to reduce their prison sentences by paying a fine Dominic College 1 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Eight Round 3 Class 8 1
1 April 2015 S2015DC014 That we should raise the retirement age to 70 Hobart College 2 Hobart College 4 Southern Schools 2015 College Round 2 College 9
1 April 2015 S2015D8B05 That older Australians should look after themselves financially Taroona High School 1 Fahan School 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Eight Round 2 Class 8 2
11 March 2015 S2015DT006 That we should introduce country-of-origin labels The Hutchins School 1 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Ten Round 1 Class 10 2.5

Accreditation history

Level Valid from Valid to
Level 5 12 May 2016 6:40 PM Does not expire
Level 4 2 April 2015 12:00 AM 12 May 2016 6:40 PM
Level 1 11 March 2015 12:00 AM 2 April 2015 12:00 AM