Peter Legg (Adjudicator: Level 5)

Peter is also a debater. You may wish to look at his debater profile.

Average scores

# Matter Manner Method POI Total Rank
S* 606 30.21 30.40 15.00 +0.09 75.64 3.50
R* 66 14.94 15.27 7.45 37.66
1A 101 30.04 30.12 15.12 +0.21 75.35 3.88
2A 101 30.28 30.43 15.00 0.00 75.70 3.42
3A 101 30.07 30.49 14.93 +0.24 75.56 3.65
RA 33 14.92 15.26 7.42 37.61
1N 101 30.19 30.45 15.10 +0.12 75.77 3.40
2N 101 30.31 30.33 14.87 +0.03 75.51 3.60
3N 101 30.39 30.60 14.96 -0.06 75.93 3.06
RN 33 14.95 15.27 7.48 37.71

Adjudications

Date Debate Topic Affirmative Negative Round Rules Margin
31 July 2024 S2024D9SF1 That we should prioritise promotion of ecotourism over preservation of the natural environment The Hutchins School 1 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2024 Grade Nine Semi finals Class 9 4
3 July 2024 S2024D8SF1 That we should convert national parks into housing developments Hobart City High School 1 Clarence High School 1 Southern Schools 2024 Grade Eight Semi finals Class 8 10
3 July 2024 S2024DNSF2 That public transport should be free St Michael's Collegiate 3 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2024 Novice Semi finals Novice 3
26 June 2019 S2019D8SF2 That all students should be required to study the arts The Friends' School 2 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Eight Semi finals Class 8 4
26 June 2019 S2019D8SF1 That all students should be required to study the arts The Friends' School 1 Ogilvie High School 1 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Eight Semi finals Class 8 2
27 March 2019 S2019D9009 That we should stop shopping online Clarence High School 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Nine Round 2 Class 9 4
27 March 2019 S2019D8017 That we should implement a universal basic income Taroona High School 3 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Eight Round 2 Class 8 4
13 March 2019 S2019DT002 That approval for major developments should be determined by a community vote The Friends' School 2 Fahan School 1 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Ten Round 1 Class 10 5
13 March 2019 S2019D8009 That recycling is a waste of time Taroona High School 2 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Eight Round 1 Class 8 2
13 March 2019 S2019D8008 That recycling is a waste of time Taroona High School 6 Calvin Christian School 1 Southern Schools 2019 Grade Eight Round 1 Class 8 4
15 August 2018 S2018D9SF1 That social media should not be available to people under the age of eighteen St Michael's Collegiate 2 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Nine Semi finals Class 9 2
4 July 2018 S2018DTGF1 That we should ban research into artificial intelligence Taroona High School 1 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Ten Grand final Class 10 4
4 July 2018 S2018D8GF1 That animal testing should be banned New Town High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 2 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Eight Grand final Class 8 1
27 June 2018 S2018D9SF2 That we should ban mobile phones from schools St Mary's College 1 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Nine Semi finals Class 9 4
27 June 2018 S2018D8SF1 That parents should only be permitted to work during the hours their children are at school Taroona High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 2 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Eight Semi finals Class 8 1
27 June 2018 S2018DNSF2 That children should not be able to purchase junk food Taroona High School 1 Calvin Christian School 2 Southern Schools 2018 Novice Semi finals Novice 2
6 June 2018 S2018DT046 That we should open our borders to climate refugees St Mary's College 1 Taroona High School 3 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Ten Round 6 Class 10 10
6 June 2018 S2018D9048 That we should prioritise individual privacy over national security St Aloysius Catholic College 1 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Nine Round 6 Class 9 5
23 May 2018 S2018DT036 That all schools which offer grades eleven and twelve should be coeducational St Aloysius Catholic College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Ten Round 5 Class 10 3.5
23 May 2018 S2018D9039 That all students should be required to study the arts The Friends' School 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Nine Round 5 Class 9 2
23 May 2018 S2018D8034 That the school age should be lowered St Michael's Collegiate 1 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Eight Round 5 Class 8 5
2 May 2018 S2018DC019 That we should tie foreign aid to emissions reduction The Friends' School 3 Elizabeth College 1 Southern Schools 2018 College Round 3 College 13
2 May 2018 S2018DN017 That we should build a cable car on Mount Wellington / kunanyi Fahan School 1 Ogilvie High School 2 Southern Schools 2018 Novice Round 3 Novice 4
2 May 2018 S2018DN055 That we should build a cable car on Mount Wellington / kunanyi Taroona High School 4 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2018 Novice Round 3 Novice 4
4 April 2018 S2018DC012 That celebrities should stay out of the feminist movement Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 2 Southern Schools 2018 College Round 2 College 2
4 April 2018 S2018DN010 That we should ban beauty pageants Ogilvie High School 2 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2018 Novice Round 2 Novice 2
4 April 2018 S2018DN051 That we should ban beauty pageants Ogilvie High School 3 St Aloysius Catholic College 2 Southern Schools 2018 Novice Round 2 Novice 2
21 March 2018 S2018DC003 That, where no party can form majority government after a Tasmanian election, a re-election should automatically be held The Friends' School 3 St Michael's Collegiate 2 Southern Schools 2018 College Round 1 College 6
21 March 2018 S2018DN048 That young Tasmanians should be able to vote New Town High School 1 Taroona High School 6 Southern Schools 2018 Novice Round 1 Novice 1
14 March 2018 S2018DT008 That we should ban all financial donations to Tasmanian political parties St Aloysius Catholic College 1 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Ten Round 1 Class 10 6.5
14 March 2018 S2018D9006 That we should ban poker machines from pubs and clubs New Town High School 1 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Nine Round 1 Class 9 1
14 March 2018 S2018D8004 That we should reduce the number of local councils in Tasmania Clarence High School 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2018 Grade Eight Round 1 Class 8 10
31 July 2017 S2017DCSF1 That we should abolish the ATAR The Friends' School 4 The Hutchins School 3 Southern Schools 2017 College Semi finals College 6.5
5 July 2017 S2017DNGF1 That every student should learn a foreign language Taroona High School 1 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2017 Novice Grand final Novice 2
28 June 2017 S2017D8SF2 That school attendance should be voluntary Taroona High School 4 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Semi finals Class 8 1
28 June 2017 S2017D8SF1 That the school age should be lowered The Friends' School 2 New Town High School 2 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Semi finals Class 8 4
14 June 2017 S2017D8027 That democracy is no longer the best form of government St Mary's College 1 New Town High School 2 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Round 6 Class 8 3
7 June 2017 S2017DN048 That Australia should become a republic Taroona High School 1 St Mary's College 1 Southern Schools 2017 Novice Round 6 Novice 2
31 May 2017 S2017DT030 That Instagram is an art form Fahan School 1 Ogilvie High School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Ten Round 5 Class 10 4
31 May 2017 S2017D8025 That we should only study modern literature Taroona High School 4 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Round 5 Class 8 2
31 May 2017 S2017D8055 That funding public libraries is a waste of money Taroona High School 2 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Round 5 Class 8 1
17 May 2017 S2017DT020 That criminal trials should be televised The Hutchins School 1 Dominic College 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Ten Round 4 Class 10 2
17 May 2017 S2017D8017 That fines should be proportional to income The Friends' School 2 St Mary's College 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Round 4 Class 8 5
17 May 2017 S2017D8047 That fines should be proportional to income Taroona High School 3 Ogilvie High School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Round 4 Class 8 4
10 May 2017 S2017DC029 That juries should return "not guilty" verdicts where they believe it would be unjust for defendants to be punished The Friends' School 1 Fahan School 1 Southern Schools 2017 College Round 4 College 10
10 May 2017 S2017D9022 That we should break unjust laws Ogilvie High School 2 Ogilvie High School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Nine Round 4 Class 9 1
10 May 2017 S2017DN029 That school rules should be made by students The Friends' School 2 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2017 Novice Round 4 Novice 2
12 April 2017 S2017DN018 That we should spend more on defence St Mary's College 2 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Novice Round 3 Novice 1
29 March 2017 S2017DC015 That we should eliminate agricultural subsidies St Mary's College 1 Guilford Young College 2 Southern Schools 2017 College Round 2 College 1.5
29 March 2017 S2017D9014 That we should ban intensive animal farming St Mary's College 1 Fahan School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Nine Round 2 Class 9 2
29 March 2017 S2017DN015 That every household should have a vegetable garden Ogilvie High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2017 Novice Round 2 Novice 3
22 March 2017 S2017DT006 That homeschooling should be banned Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Ten Round 1 Class 10 1.5
22 March 2017 S2017D8005 That smacking should be banned St Mary's College 1 Taroona High School 6 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Eight Round 1 Class 8 2
15 March 2017 S2017DC004 That we should implement parenting licences The Hutchins School 1 The Friends' School 4 Southern Schools 2017 College Round 1 College 8
15 March 2017 S2017D9004 That childcare should be free Dominic College 2 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2017 Grade Nine Round 1 Class 9 3
15 March 2017 S2017DN004 That children should be paid to do chores The Hutchins School 1 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2017 Novice Round 1 Novice 4
21 September 2016 S2016DCGF1 That public healthcare should not be available to high income earners The Friends' School 1 Elizabeth College 2 Southern Schools 2016 College Grand final College 1.5
20 July 2016 S2016DCSF2 That we should privatise the ABC Elizabeth College 2 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2016 College Semi finals College 2
29 June 2016 S2016D9GF1 That there should be a tax on sugary drinks St Mary's College 1 Ogilvie High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Grand final Class 9 4
29 June 2016 S2016D8GF1 That all students should be required to play sport at lunchtime Taroona High School 2 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Eight Grand final Class 8 5
22 June 2016 S2016D9SF2 That the arts should be removed from the Australian curriculum The Friends' School 1 Ogilvie High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Semi finals Class 9 1
22 June 2016 S2016D9SF1 That all students should be required to study the arts St Mary's College 1 St Mary's College 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Semi finals Class 9 2
8 June 2016 S2016DT036 That there should be quotas for women in the Australian Parliament Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Ten Round 6 Class 10 4
8 June 2016 S2016D9033 That politicians should be paid more The Friends' School 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Round 6 Class 9 2
1 June 2016 S2016DC048 That the leaders of political parties should be democratically elected Elizabeth College 2 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2016 College Round 6 College 2.5
1 June 2016 S2016DN027 That the voting age should be lowered New Town High School 1 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 6 Novice 1
1 June 2016 S2016DN054 That the voting age should be lowered Taroona High School 6 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 6 Novice 3
25 May 2016 S2016DT029 That we should ban the burning of fossil fuels The Friends' School 2 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Ten Round 5 Class 10 2.5
25 May 2016 S2016D9026 That access to national parks should be free Fahan School 1 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Round 5 Class 9 4
25 May 2016 S2016D8030 That we should ban tourism in national parks The Hutchins School 2 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Eight Round 5 Class 8 1
11 May 2016 S2016DT021 That judges should be elected The Friends' School 3 The Hutchins School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Ten Round 4 Class 10 3.5
4 May 2016 S2016DC030 That judicial activism is bad for democracy Fahan School 1 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2016 College Round 4 College 1.5
4 May 2016 S2016DN018 That parents should be held responsible for crimes committed by their children Dominic College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 4 Novice 8
4 May 2016 S2016DN045 That parents should be held responsible for crimes committed by their children The Hutchins School 1 Taroona High School 4 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 4 Novice 2
6 April 2016 S2016DC020 That the Australian government should not comment on human right abuses in other countries The Friends' School 2 The Hutchins School 2 Southern Schools 2016 College Round 3 College 0.5
6 April 2016 S2016DN013 That we should change the date of Australia Day New Town High School 1 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 3 Novice 1
30 March 2016 S2016DT010 That broadcasters should be required to cover women's and men's sport equally Clarence High School 1 Dominic College 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Ten Round 2 Class 10 4
30 March 2016 S2016D9010 That we should abolish marriage The Friends' School 2 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Round 2 Class 9 1
30 March 2016 S2016D8011 That we should ban beauty pageants Dominic College 1 Fahan School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Eight Round 2 Class 8 4
23 March 2016 S2016DC013 That feminists should publicly denounce female celebrities who return to abusive partners The Friends' School 3 Elizabeth College 3 Southern Schools 2016 College Round 2 College 11
23 March 2016 S2016DN009 That all schools should be coeducational Mount Carmel College 1 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 2 Novice 2
23 March 2016 S2016DN038 That all schools should be coeducational Taroona High School 4 Ogilvie High School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Novice Round 2 Novice 1
16 March 2016 S2016DT002 That Tasmania should introduce selective schools The Friends' School 1 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Ten Round 1 Class 10 3.5
16 March 2016 S2016D9002 That all school students should do the same subjects St Michael's Collegiate 1 New Town High School 1 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Round 1 Class 9 1
16 March 2016 S2016D8002 That school attendance should be voluntary New Town High School 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Eight Round 1 Class 8 3
9 March 2016 S2016DC003 That schools should be able to monitor students' browsing The Hutchins School 1 Hobart College 3 Southern Schools 2016 College Round 1 College 6
9 March 2016 S2016D9006 That all school students should do the same subjects St Mary's College 1 St Mary's College 2 Southern Schools 2016 Grade Nine Round 1 Class 9 3
24 June 2015 S2015DTSF1 That only applied science is worth funding Taroona High School 1 The Hutchins School 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Ten Round 7 Class 10 1
24 June 2015 S2015D9SF2 That we should send settlers to Mars Taroona High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Nine Round 7 Class 9 1
24 June 2015 S2015D8SF1 That science is the best guide for life New Town High School 2 St Mary's College 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Eight Round 7 Class 8 3
27 May 2015 S2015DT029 That we should spend more on defence St Michael's Collegiate 1 The Friends' School 2 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Ten Round 5 Class 10 2.5
27 May 2015 S2015DN034 That we should change our national flag Taroona High School 3 St Mary's College 1 Southern Schools 2015 Novice Round 5 Novice 1
27 May 2015 S2015D9023 That we value our sportspeople too highly Fahan School 1 St Mary's College 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Nine Round 5 Class 9 6
20 May 2015 S2015DC024 That we should tax high income parents for sending their kids to public school St Michael's Collegiate 1 Hobart College 3 Southern Schools 2015 College Round 4 College 2
20 May 2015 S2015D8R14 That we need more practical classes at school The Hutchins School 2 Dominic College 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Eight Round 4 Class 8 1
20 May 2015 S2015D8B14 That all high schools should go to Grade 12 Fahan School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Eight Round 4 Class 8 6
6 May 2015 S2015DC021 That we should end custodial sentences for minors Hobart College 2 The Hutchins School 2 Southern Schools 2015 College Round 3 College 9.5
6 May 2015 S2015D8R11 That criminals should be able to reduce their prison sentences by paying a fine Dominic College 1 Taroona High School 2 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Eight Round 3 Class 8 1
1 April 2015 S2015DC014 That we should raise the retirement age to 70 Hobart College 2 Hobart College 4 Southern Schools 2015 College Round 2 College 9
1 April 2015 S2015D8B05 That older Australians should look after themselves financially Taroona High School 1 Fahan School 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Eight Round 2 Class 8 2
11 March 2015 S2015DT006 That we should introduce country-of-origin labels The Hutchins School 1 Taroona High School 1 Southern Schools 2015 Grade Ten Round 1 Class 10 2.5

Accreditation history

Level Valid from Valid to
Level 5 12 May 2016 6:40 PM Does not expire
Level 4 2 April 2015 12:00 AM 12 May 2016 6:40 PM
Level 1 11 March 2015 12:00 AM 2 April 2015 12:00 AM