Lisette is also an adjudicator. You may wish to look at her adjudicator profile.

Average scores

# Matter Manner Method POI Total Rank
S* 28 30.68 30.54 14.93 +0.27 76.29 2.57
R* 7 14.71 14.93 7.14 36.79
1A 10 30.70 30.80 14.80 +0.50 76.50 2.30
2A 2 31.00 30.00 15.00 0.00 76.00 2.50
3A 2 30.50 30.00 15.00 0.00 75.50 3.50
RA 4 14.50 14.88 7.13 36.50
1N 7 30.43 30.29 15.00 +0.50 75.86 2.86
2N 3 31.00 30.67 14.67 +0.50 76.67 2.33
3N 4 30.75 30.75 15.25 0.00 76.75 2.50
RN 3 15.00 15.00 7.17 37.17

Substantive speeches

Date Debate Topic Team Against Position Matter Manner Method POI Total Rank
13 June 2018 S2018DC040 That we should introduce the death penalty for perpetrators of crimes against humanity Elizabeth College 2 Elizabeth College 1 1N 29 29 15 0 73 5
16 May 2018 S2018DC024 That previous incarceration should be a mitigating factor in sentencing Elizabeth College 2 St Michael's Collegiate 2 2N 32 30 14 0 76 1
2 May 2018 S2018DC016 That we should implement a global ban on commercial fishing Elizabeth College 2 The Friends' School 2 1A 30 30 16 0 76 3
4 April 2018 S2018DC008 That feminists in Western nations should focus on campaigning for women’s rights in the developing world Elizabeth College 2 Hobart College 2 3N 31 31 16 +1 79 2
21 March 2018 S2018DC007 That the Tasmanian Greens and the Tasmanian Labor Party should form a permanent coalition Elizabeth College 2 The Friends' School 1 1A 30 30 15 0 75 4
7 June 2017 S2017DC042 That we should all join a political party Elizabeth College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 3N 31 31 15 0 77 1
24 May 2017 S2017DC033 That we should not consume art created by immoral artists Elizabeth College 1 Hobart College 1 2A 31 30 15 0 76 2
10 May 2017 S2017DC032 That juries should return "not guilty" verdicts where they believe it would be unjust for defendants to be punished Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 2 3N 31 30 15 -1 75 4
12 April 2017 S2017DC023 That we should fight terror with torture Elizabeth College 1 St Mary's College 1 2A 31 30 15 0 76 3
29 March 2017 S2017DC014 That we should limit foreign ownership of agricultural land Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 3 3N 30 31 15 0 76 3
15 March 2017 S2017DC005 That we should implement parenting licences Elizabeth College 1 The Friends' School 1 3A 31 30 15 0 76 2
8 June 2016 S2016DT031 That there should be quotas for women in the Australian Parliament Ogilvie High School 1 The Friends' School 1 1A 30 31 14 +1 76 3
27 April 2016 S2016DT013 That we should permit traditional hunting of endangered species by Aboriginal Australians Ogilvie High School 1 New Town High School 1 1N 31 31 15 +1 78 1
30 March 2016 S2016DT007 That we should ban the digital alteration of images in beauty magazines Ogilvie High School 1 The Hutchins School 2 1A 32 31 15 +1 79 1
16 March 2016 S2016DT001 That Tasmania should introduce selective schools Ogilvie High School 1 The Friends' School 2 2N 31 31 15 +1 78 1
1 July 2015 S2015D9GF1 That organ donation should be compulsory Ogilvie High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 1A 30 31 15 76 3
1 July 2015 S2015D9GF1 That organ donation should be compulsory Ogilvie High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 1A 30 31 14 75 4
1 July 2015 S2015D9GF1 That organ donation should be compulsory Ogilvie High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 1A 32 32 14 78 1
24 June 2015 S2015D9SF1 That space tourism will take off soon Ogilvie High School 1 New Town High School 1 1N 31 31 16 78 1
24 June 2015 S2015D9SF1 That space tourism will take off soon Ogilvie High School 1 New Town High School 1 1N 30 31 16 77 2
24 June 2015 S2015D9SF1 That space tourism will take off soon Ogilvie High School 1 New Town High School 1 1N 30 31 14 75 3
10 June 2015 S2015D9030 That we should study the classics Ogilvie High School 1 The Hutchins School 1 1A 31 31 15 77 1
27 May 2015 S2015D9024 That we value our sportspeople too highly Ogilvie High School 1 New Town High School 1 1N 30 29 14 73 6
1 April 2015 S2015D9006 That our parents owe us more than we owe them Ogilvie High School 1 St Mary's College 1 3A 30 30 15 75 5
11 March 2015 S2015D9001 That farmers should be able to "shut the gate" on mining exploration Ogilvie High School 1 The Friends' School 1 1A 31 31 15 77 1
11 June 2014 S2014D8033 That heritage buildings have outlived their usefulness Ogilvie High School 2 New Town High School 1 1N 32 30 15 77 2
9 April 2014 S2014D8018 That organ donation should be compulsory Ogilvie High School 2 St Michael's Collegiate 1 1A 31 30 15 76 2
12 March 2014 S2014D8005 That sportspeople should be role models Ogilvie High School 2 New Town High School 2 2N 30 31 15 76 5

Reply speeches

Date Debate Topic Team Against Position Matter Manner Method Total
13 June 2018 S2018DC040 That we should introduce the death penalty for perpetrators of crimes against humanity Elizabeth College 2 Elizabeth College 1 RN 15 15 8 38
2 May 2018 S2018DC016 That we should implement a global ban on commercial fishing Elizabeth College 2 The Friends' School 2 RA 15 15.5 7.5 38
21 March 2018 S2018DC007 That the Tasmanian Greens and the Tasmanian Labor Party should form a permanent coalition Elizabeth College 2 The Friends' School 1 RA 14 15 7.5 36.5
8 June 2016 S2016DT031 That there should be quotas for women in the Australian Parliament Ogilvie High School 1 The Friends' School 1 RA 15 15 7.5 37.5
27 April 2016 S2016DT013 That we should permit traditional hunting of endangered species by Aboriginal Australians Ogilvie High School 1 New Town High School 1 RN 15 15 7 37
30 March 2016 S2016DT007 That we should ban the digital alteration of images in beauty magazines Ogilvie High School 1 The Hutchins School 2 RA 14 14 6 34
16 March 2016 S2016DT001 That Tasmania should introduce selective schools Ogilvie High School 1 The Friends' School 2 RN 15 15 6.5 36.5