James Barnes (Debater)

James is also an adjudicator. You may wish to look at his adjudicator profile.

Teams

Hobart College 2 2015 · Debater Guilford Young College 1 2014 · Debater Guilford Young College 1 2013 · Debater St Aloysius School 1 2012 · Debater

Average scores

# Matter Manner Method POI Total Rank
S* 16 31.38 31.56 15.25 +0.36 78.44 1.44
3A 11 31.55 31.64 15.18 +0.63 78.82 1.27
3N 5 31.00 31.40 15.40 -0.33 77.60 1.80

Substantive speeches

Date Debate Topic Team Against Position Matter Manner Method POI Total Rank
29 July 2015 S2015DCSF1 That we should embrace nuclear power Hobart College 2 Elizabeth College 1 3A 32 32 15 0 79 3
29 July 2015 S2015DCSF1 That we should embrace nuclear power Hobart College 2 Elizabeth College 1 3A 31 32 15 0 78 1
29 July 2015 S2015DCSF1 That we should embrace nuclear power Hobart College 2 Elizabeth College 1 3A 32 32 15 0 79 1
3 June 2015 S2015DC033 That we should leave the Commonwealth Hobart College 2 The Friends' School 2 3A 31 31 16 +1 79 1
6 May 2015 S2015DC021 That we should end custodial sentences for minors Hobart College 2 The Hutchins School 2 3A 31 31 16 +2 80 1
1 April 2015 S2015DC014 That we should raise the retirement age to 70 Hobart College 2 Hobart College 4 3A 31 32 15 +1 79 1
18 March 2015 S2015DC006 That we should ban genetically modified crops Hobart College 2 Hobart College 3 3N 31 31 16 +1 79 2
16 April 2014 S2014DC022 That we support the Trans-Pacific Partnership Guilford Young College 1 Hobart College 1 3A 31 32 14 0 77 2
19 March 2014 S2014DC010 That human rights are worth going to war over Guilford Young College 1 Hobart College 2 3N 32 32 16 0 80 1
5 March 2014 S2014DC004 That we should never have gone to Sochi Guilford Young College 1 Hobart College 3 3A 32 32 15 +1 80 1
17 April 2013 S2013DC015 That fat acceptance is a dangerous culture Guilford Young College 1 The Hutchins School 1 3N 31 31 14 -2 74 4
1 August 2012 S2012D9042 That building should be banned in bushfire zones St Aloysius School 1 Fahan School 1 3A 32 32 15 79 1
18 July 2012 S2012D9036 That we should vote for policies rather than politicians St Aloysius School 1 The Friends' School 1 3A 32 31 16 79 1
9 May 2012 S2012D9015 That historical artefacts should be returned to their country of origin St Aloysius School 1 Taroona High School 1 3N 32 32 16 80 1
4 April 2012 S2012D9008 That all schools should be coeducational St Aloysius School 1 Fahan School 2 3A 32 31 15 78 1
21 March 2012 S2012D9001 That smoking should be banned in public places St Aloysius School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 3N 29 31 15 75 1