Wednesday
24 May 2023 · Mount Carmel College

Room 1 · Paul Bobenhausen

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:20 PM S2023D8019 Class 8 St Mary's College 1 Rose Bay High School 1 That criminals should be able to reduce their prison sentences by paying a fine Negative win
7:20 PM 8:20 PM S2023D9013 Class 9 The Friends' School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 That we should replace lawyers with robots Affirmative win
8:20 PM 9:30 PM S2023DT016 Class 10 MacKillop Catholic College 1 The Friends' School 1 That we should abolish juries Negative win by affirmative forfeit

Room 2 · Fiona Laycock-Taylor

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:20 PM S2023D8023 Class 8 The Friends' School 1 MacKillop Catholic College 1 That criminals should be able to reduce their prison sentences by paying a fine Affirmative win
7:20 PM 8:20 PM S2023D9015 Class 9 Clarence High School 1 Hobart City High School 1 That we should replace lawyers with robots Negative win
8:20 PM 9:30 PM S2023DT017 Class 10 Hobart City High School 1 Mount Carmel College 1 That we should abolish juries Affirmative win

Room 3 · John Hayton

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:20 PM S2023D8024 Class 8 The Hutchins School 1 Taroona High School 1 That criminals should be able to reduce their prison sentences by paying a fine Negative win
7:20 PM 8:20 PM S2023D9014 Class 9 Taroona High School 1 Clarence High School 3 That we should replace lawyers with robots Negative win
8:20 PM 9:30 PM S2023DT018 Class 10 The Hutchins School 1 St Mary's College 1 That we should abolish juries Affirmative win

Room 4 · Mel Ross

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:40 PM S2023DT019 Class 10 Huonville High School 1 Taroona High School 1 That we should abolish juries Negative win

Room 5 · Johanna Ellis

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:20 PM S2023D8020 Class 8 Mount Carmel College 1 Peregrine School 1 That criminals should be able to reduce their prison sentences by paying a fine Negative win

Room not yet allocated

Start Finish Debate Grade Affirmative Negative Topic Outcome
6:30 PM 7:20 PM S2023D8021 Class 8 St Michael's Collegiate 1 Rose Bay High School 2 That criminals should be able to reduce their prison sentences by paying a fine Affirmative win by negative forfeit