Average scores

# Matter Manner Method POI Total Rank
S* 30 30.37 30.67 14.63 +0.20 75.80 3.03
R* 9 15.06 15.11 7.50 37.67
1A 1 29.00 30.00 14.00 0.00 73.00 6.00
2A 8 30.63 30.63 15.00 +0.75 76.63 2.25
3A 7 30.57 30.71 14.57 0.00 75.86 3.86
RA 5 15.30 15.20 7.80 38.30
1N 3 29.67 30.33 14.33 +0.33 74.67 2.33
2N 4 30.75 31.25 14.75 0.00 76.75 2.00
3N 7 30.14 30.57 14.43 0.00 75.14 3.57
RN 4 14.75 15.00 7.13 36.88

Substantive speeches

Date Debate Topic Team Against Position Matter Manner Method POI Total Rank
4 July 2018 S2018DCGF1 That we should establish a publicly accessible register of individuals carrying infectious diseases Hobart College 2 The Hutchins School 1 3A 32 32 15 0 79 2
4 July 2018 S2018DCGF1 That we should establish a publicly accessible register of individuals carrying infectious diseases Hobart College 2 The Hutchins School 1 3A 30 31 14 0 75 6
4 July 2018 S2018DCGF1 That we should establish a publicly accessible register of individuals carrying infectious diseases Hobart College 2 The Hutchins School 1 3A 31 31 15 0 77 3
27 June 2018 S2018DCSF2 That public healthcare should not be available to high income earners Hobart College 2 The Friends' School 2 3N 30 30 14 0 74 6
27 June 2018 S2018DCSF2 That public healthcare should not be available to high income earners Hobart College 2 The Friends' School 2 3N 30 31 15 0 76 2
13 June 2018 S2018DC036 That the Australian government should not attempt to secure pardons for Australian citizens who have been sentenced to death overseas Hobart College 2 The Friends' School 3 3A 31 31 15 0 77 2
2 May 2018 S2018DC015 That we should tie foreign aid to emissions reduction Hobart College 2 Guilford Young College 1 3N 31 31 14 0 76 3
21 March 2018 S2018DC001 That, where no party can form majority government after a Tasmanian election, a re-election should automatically be held Hobart College 2 The Hutchins School 1 1N 30 30 15 0 75 2
7 June 2017 S2017DC041 That we should all join a political party Hobart College 1 The Hutchins School 1 3A 31 31 14 0 76 4
24 May 2017 S2017DC033 That we should not consume art created by immoral artists Hobart College 1 Elizabeth College 1 2N 31 30 15 0 76 3
10 May 2017 S2017DC025 That juries should return "not guilty" verdicts where they believe it would be unjust for defendants to be punished Hobart College 1 Guilford Young College 2 3A 29 30 14 0 73 5
15 March 2017 S2017DC001 That we should implement parenting licences Hobart College 1 The Friends' School 3 3N 29 30 14 0 73 4
22 June 2016 S2016DTSF1 That the government should not subsidise arts and cultural festivals Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 1 2A 30 31 14 0 75 4
22 June 2016 S2016DTSF1 That the government should not subsidise arts and cultural festivals Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 1 2A 29 31 14 +1 75 3
22 June 2016 S2016DTSF1 That the government should not subsidise arts and cultural festivals Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 1 2A 30 30 15 +2 77 3
8 June 2016 S2016DT036 That there should be quotas for women in the Australian Parliament Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 2 1A 29 30 14 0 73 6
25 May 2016 S2016DT030 That we should put a price on carbon Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 1 1N 29 31 14 0 74 4
27 April 2016 S2016DT018 That access to Aboriginal sacred sites should be restricted Taroona High School 1 Fahan School 1 1N 30 30 14 +1 75 1
30 March 2016 S2016DT012 That broadcasters should be required to cover women's and men's sport equally Taroona High School 1 New Town High School 1 2A 31 31 14 0 76 1
16 March 2016 S2016DT006 That Tasmania should introduce selective schools Taroona High School 1 The Hutchins School 2 2N 31 32 14 0 77 2
27 May 2015 S2015D9021 That we value our sportspeople too highly Taroona High School 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 2N 31 32 15 78 1
13 May 2015 S2015D9016 That we should stream classes by ability instead of age Taroona High School 1 Clarence High School 1 3N 30 31 15 76 1
29 April 2015 S2015D9012 That Australia should introduce separate courts for indigenous Australians Taroona High School 1 Ogilvie High School 1 2A 31 29 16 76 2
25 March 2015 S2015D9008 That our parents owe us more than we owe them Taroona High School 1 The Hutchins School 1 3N 30 30 15 75 6
11 March 2015 S2015D9004 That farmers should be able to "shut the gate" on mining exploration Taroona High School 1 Fahan School 1 2A 32 31 16 79 1
11 June 2014 S2014D8031 That heritage buildings have outlived their usefulness Taroona High School 1 The Hutchins School 1 2N 30 31 15 76 2
28 May 2014 S2014D8025 That fiction is better than non-fiction Taroona High School 1 New Town High School 2 3A 30 29 15 74 5
9 April 2014 S2014D8013 That organ donation should be compulsory Taroona High School 1 Ogilvie High School 1 2A 31 30 15 76 3
26 March 2014 S2014D8007 That zoos should be abolished Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 1 3N 31 31 14 76 3
12 March 2014 S2014D8001 That sportspeople should be role models Taroona High School 1 Fahan School 1 2A 31 32 16 79 1

Reply speeches

Date Debate Topic Team Against Position Matter Manner Method Total
21 March 2018 S2018DC001 That, where no party can form majority government after a Tasmanian election, a re-election should automatically be held Hobart College 2 The Hutchins School 1 RN 15 15 7 37
22 June 2016 S2016DTSF1 That the government should not subsidise arts and cultural festivals Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 1 RA 15 15 7.5 37.5
22 June 2016 S2016DTSF1 That the government should not subsidise arts and cultural festivals Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 1 RA 15.5 15 8 38.5
22 June 2016 S2016DTSF1 That the government should not subsidise arts and cultural festivals Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 1 RA 15.5 15 8 38.5
8 June 2016 S2016DT036 That there should be quotas for women in the Australian Parliament Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 2 RA 14.5 15 7.5 37
25 May 2016 S2016DT030 That we should put a price on carbon Taroona High School 1 The Friends' School 1 RN 14.5 15 7 36.5
27 April 2016 S2016DT018 That access to Aboriginal sacred sites should be restricted Taroona High School 1 Fahan School 1 RN 14.5 15 7.5 37
30 March 2016 S2016DT012 That broadcasters should be required to cover women's and men's sport equally Taroona High School 1 New Town High School 1 RA 16 16 8 40
16 March 2016 S2016DT006 That Tasmania should introduce selective schools Taroona High School 1 The Hutchins School 2 RN 15 15 7 37