Kathryn is also an adjudicator. You may wish to look at her adjudicator profile.

Average scores

# Matter Manner Method POI Total Rank
S* 24 31.42 31.63 15.38 +0.88 79.29 1.25
R* 12 15.88 15.71 7.88 39.46
1A 9 31.78 31.89 15.78 +0.89 80.33 1.11
3A 3 31.67 32.33 15.33 +0.67 80.00 1.33
RA 9 15.83 15.61 7.78 39.22
1N 2 32.00 32.00 16.00 0.00 80.00 1.00
2N 1 32.00 30.00 15.00 +1.00 78.00 3.00
3N 9 30.78 31.22 14.89 +1.11 78.00 1.22
RN 3 16.00 16.00 8.17 40.17

Substantive speeches

Date Debate Topic Team Against Position Matter Manner Method POI Total Rank
3 July 2013 S2013DCGF1 That there is no artistic integrity in the internet age Elizabeth College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 1A 32 32 16 +1 81 1
3 July 2013 S2013DCGF1 That there is no artistic integrity in the internet age Elizabeth College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 1A 32 31 16 +1 80 1
3 July 2013 S2013DCGF1 That there is no artistic integrity in the internet age Elizabeth College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 1A 33 33 17 +1 84 1
25 June 2013 S2013DCSF1 That we should have quotas for women on company boards Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 1 1A 33 34 16 +1 84 1
5 June 2013 S2013DC025 That we should permit traditional hunting of endangered species by Aboriginal Australians Elizabeth College 1 Fahan School 1 1A 31 32 15 +2 80 1
8 May 2013 S2013DC008 That we should eliminate agricultural subsidies Elizabeth College 1 The Friends' School 1 1A 32 32 16 +1 81 1
17 April 2013 S2013DC014 That fat acceptance is a dangerous culture Elizabeth College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 2 2N 32 30 15 +1 78 3
20 March 2013 S2013DC002 That there is a place for violent protest Elizabeth College 1 Hobart College 1 1N 33 33 17 0 83 1
5 September 2012 S2012DCGF1 That travellers should be subject to the law of their home nation Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 1 1A 31 31 15 +1 78 2
5 September 2012 S2012DCGF1 That travellers should be subject to the law of their home nation Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 1 1A 31 31 16 0 78 1
5 September 2012 S2012DCGF1 That travellers should be subject to the law of their home nation Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 1 1A 31 31 15 0 77 1
29 August 2012 S2012DCSF1 That oral history isn't history at all Elizabeth College 1 Hobart College 1 1N 31 31 15 0 77 1
15 August 2012 S2012DC023 That we are only free every four years Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 2 3N 31 31 14 +1 77 2
27 June 2012 S2012DC020 That mass animal slaughter is genocide Elizabeth College 1 Hobart College 1 3A 33 34 15 0 82 2
28 March 2012 S2012DC006 That independent schools should not receive government funding Elizabeth College 1 The Friends' School 1 3A 32 32 15 +2 81 1
14 March 2012 S2012DC001 That parents should not be able to decline medical treatment for their children Elizabeth College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 3N 30 32 15 0 77 1
5 October 2011 S2011DTSF2 That politics should focus on policy rather than polls Ogilvie High School 1 New Town High School 1 3N 31 30 15 +2 78 1
5 October 2011 S2011DTSF2 That politics should focus on policy rather than polls Ogilvie High School 1 New Town High School 1 3N 31 32 15 +2 80 1
5 October 2011 S2011DTSF2 That politics should focus on policy rather than polls Ogilvie High School 1 New Town High School 1 3N 29 31 15 +1 76 2
10 August 2011 S2011DT091 That tourism in Antarctica should be banned Ogilvie High School 1 Fahan School 1 3N 31 31 15 +1 78 1
27 July 2011 S2011DT086 That we should ban Holocaust denial Ogilvie High School 1 The Friends' School 1 3N 33 32 16 +1 82 1
13 July 2011 S2011DT080 That we spend too much on defence Ogilvie High School 1 Kingston High School 1 3A 30 31 16 0 77 1
29 June 2011 S2011DT074 That science is just another religion Ogilvie High School 1 St Mary's College 1 3N 31 30 15 +1 77 1
30 March 2011 S2011DT002 That we should open our borders to climate refugees Ogilvie High School 1 Rose Bay High School 1 3N 30 32 14 +1 77 1

Reply speeches

Date Debate Topic Team Against Position Matter Manner Method Total
3 July 2013 S2013DCGF1 That there is no artistic integrity in the internet age Elizabeth College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 RA 16 15 8 39
3 July 2013 S2013DCGF1 That there is no artistic integrity in the internet age Elizabeth College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 RA 15 15 8 38
3 July 2013 S2013DCGF1 That there is no artistic integrity in the internet age Elizabeth College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 1 RA 16 18 8 42
25 June 2013 S2013DCSF1 That we should have quotas for women on company boards Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 1 RA 17 16 8 41
5 June 2013 S2013DC025 That we should permit traditional hunting of endangered species by Aboriginal Australians Elizabeth College 1 Fahan School 1 RA 15.5 15.5 8 39
8 May 2013 S2013DC008 That we should eliminate agricultural subsidies Elizabeth College 1 The Friends' School 1 RA 16 16 8.5 40.5
17 April 2013 S2013DC014 That fat acceptance is a dangerous culture Elizabeth College 1 St Michael's Collegiate 2 RN 16 16 8 40
20 March 2013 S2013DC002 That there is a place for violent protest Elizabeth College 1 Hobart College 1 RN 16 16 8 40
5 September 2012 S2012DCGF1 That travellers should be subject to the law of their home nation Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 1 RA 16 15 7.5 38.5
5 September 2012 S2012DCGF1 That travellers should be subject to the law of their home nation Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 1 RA 16 15 7 38
5 September 2012 S2012DCGF1 That travellers should be subject to the law of their home nation Elizabeth College 1 The Hutchins School 1 RA 15 15 7 37
29 August 2012 S2012DCSF1 That oral history isn't history at all Elizabeth College 1 Hobart College 1 RN 16 16 8.5 40.5